17 Best Places to Shop in New Buffalo, MI

Choose Chad Team April 24, 2024

New Buffalo, Mich., offers more than stunning lakefront vistas and charming beaches. Beyond the natural beauty lies a vibrant shopping scene catering to diverse tastes and styles. For a town of its size, New Buffalo has many retail options. Whether you're seeking unique home decor, trendy apparel, or the perfect souvenir, shopping in New Buffalo, MI, presents a delightful experience. 

Let's explore some of New Buffalo’s must-visit stores.

For the fashionable

  • No. 44: Embrace coastal chic at No. 44, featuring women's apparel and accessories focusing on natural fabrics and timeless styles. Discover comfortable yet stylish clothing perfect for a day at the beach or a charming evening out. From chic dresses to artisan jewelry, No. 44 has something for fashion-forward shoppers of all ages.
  • Indian Summer Boutique: Indian Summer Boutique is another must-visit destination for fashion enthusiasts. Find curated collections of dresses, tops, and accessories reflecting the latest trends and offering a sophisticated touch to your wardrobe. Whether you're searching for cozy sweaters or statement jewelry, Indian Summer Boutique has you covered.
  • POSH Upscale Consignment: POSH Upscale Consignment is a treasure trove of designer finds at affordable prices. This upscale consignment shop offers gently used clothing, accessories, and home decor from top designer brands. Browse luxury apparel, handbags, and shoes from prominent brands at a fraction of the retail price. You might just find a hidden gem!
  • The Hidden Gem: For those seeking unique and one-of-a-kind treasures, The Hidden Gem is a must-visit destination. As the name suggests, The Hidden Gem offers unique women's clothing and accessories you won't find elsewhere. Explore their eclectic mix of styles, from bohemian chic to vintage-inspired pieces, to add a touch of personality to your outfit.

For the home and more

  • Eastern Standard Time: Eastern Standard Time is a boutique specializing in timeless, classic fashion for men and women. This stylish shop in downtown New Buffalo offers a curated selection of clothing, accessories, and footwear from top brands. Discover curated collections of furniture, art, and handcrafted gifts that add a touch of sophistication and personality to your space.
  • Lakeside Goods: For those searching for home decor and gifts, Lakeside Goods is the place to be. This cozy shop offers a curated selection of handcrafted goods, including pottery, candles, and artwork from local artisans and makers. Lakeside Goods has a wide variety of items, all with a rustic, lakeside vibe.
  • The Love Spell Boutique: The Love Spell Boutique is a whimsical shop offering a curated selection of bohemian-inspired clothing, accessories, and gifts. This charming boutique is located in downtown New Buffalo and features flowy dresses, embroidered tops, and handmade jewelry, perfect for free-spirited fashionistas.

Fun and practical

  • T-Shirt Factory: Create lasting memories with custom t-shirts and souvenirs at T-Shirt Factory. Find a wide selection of New Buffalo-themed apparel and gifts, or personalize your creation to capture your unique vacation experience.
  • New Buffalo Art Gallery: Immerse yourself in the local art scene at New Buffalo Art Gallery. Browse paintings, sculptures, and mixed media artwork by talented local artists and bring a piece of New Buffalo's creative spirit home.
  • Barney's: Barney's is a beloved institution in downtown New Buffalo. The market and grocery store is located downtown and offers a wide selection of fresh produce, meats, and specialty items. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, it's a favorite among locals and visitors alike for its quality products and convenient location.
  • The Kid's Stop: The Kid's Stop is a charming children's boutique offering a curated selection of clothing, toys, and gifts for kids of all ages. Discover educational and engaging activities perfect for children of all ages, ensuring a fun and memorable vacation for the whole family.

Beyond the Mainstream

  • Stray Dog Gear: Stray Dog Gear is a must-visit destination for outdoor enthusiasts. Located in downtown New Buffalo, this adventure outfitter offers a wide variety of gear and apparel for hiking, camping, fishing, and more.
  • Frolic: Frolic is a charming boutique offering a curated selection of clothing, accessories, and gifts for women. Located in downtown New Buffalo, this stylish shop features a variety of on-trend items, including dresses, tops, jewelry, and handbags.
  • Customs Imports: Customs Imports is a unique shop offering a curated selection of handmade goods worldwide. Explore their eclectic mix of furniture, home decor, jewelry, and gifts, bringing a touch of global flair to your home.

Essentials and activities

  • New Buffalo True Value: Find all the essentials for your stay at New Buffalo True Value. This full-service hardware store offers various products, including tools, paint, and plumbing supplies. Stock up on groceries, household items, and beach supplies, ensuring a convenient and well-equipped vacation.
  • Sweetwater Boating Supplies: Sweetwater Boating Supplies is a one-stop shop for all your boating and marine needs. Find everything from life jackets and anchors to fishing gear and boat care products. Whether you're a seasoned sailor or just starting, Sweetwater Boating Supplies has everything you need to enjoy a day on the water.
  • Pedego Electric Bikes Harbor Country: Pedego Electric Bikes is a fun and unique way to explore the beautiful lakeside scenery of New Buffalo. The shop offers various pedal-assist bikes for rent or purchase, perfect for cruising along the lakefront or exploring the town's charming streets.

Shop with Confidence in New Buffalo

Shopping in New Buffalo offers a delightful mix of boutiques, galleries, and specialty stores, perfect for those looking to indulge in retail therapy or find the ideal gift. From trendy fashion boutiques to charming home decor shops, there's something for everyone in this lovely lakeside town. So, next time you're in the area, check out one of these top-rated establishments for a memorable shopping experience.

Interested in relocating?

For those considering making New Buffalo their home and exploring real estate options in the area, don't hesitate to contact The Choose Chad Team. With their expertise and knowledge of the local market, they can help you find the perfect property to call home in this charming lakeside community. Reach out to The Choose Chad Team to start your journey toward finding your dream home in New Buffalo, Michigan.

*Header photo courtesy of PrivaDrive

Work With Us

Don't miss out on the unparalleled expertise and personalized service offered by Chad Gradowski and the ChooseChad Team. Whether you're buying or selling a home, trust the #1 Real Estate Agent in Southwest Michigan to guide you towards success. Contact Chad today to make your real estate goals a reality.