New Buffalo, Mich., nestled along the shores of Lake Michigan, offers a delightful culinary scene that caters to various tastes and preferences. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, gourmet burgers, or authentic Italian cuisine, this charming lakeside town has something to satisfy every palate. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries with waterfront views, the best restaurants in New Buffalo offer a culinary experience that will delight locals and visitors alike.
Join us as we explore some of the top dining destinations in New Buffalo.
1. The Stray Dog Bar & Grill
245 N. Whittaker St.
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill is a beloved dining establishment in downtown New Buffalo. Known for its laid-back atmosphere, friendly service, and mouthwatering menu, The Stray Dog is a favorite among locals and tourists. Guests can enjoy different dishes, including gourmet burgers, fresh salads, and signature sandwiches, all made with high-quality ingredients. With its spacious outdoor patio overlooking the marina, The Stray Dog is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a delicious meal while taking in the scenic views of Lake Michigan.
2. Redamak's
616 E. Buffalo St.
For over 40 years,
Redamak's has been a staple in the New Buffalo dining scene, renowned for its classic American fare and nostalgic ambiance. This family-owned restaurant is famous for its mouthwatering burgers, made with freshly ground beef and served on a toasted bun with all the fixings. In addition to its legendary burgers, Redamak's also offers a variety of other comfort food classics, including hot dogs, sandwiches, and crispy onion rings. With its retro diner decor and friendly service, Redamak's provides a dining experience that feels like a step back in time.
3. Bentwood Tavern
600 W. Water St.
Located inside the Marina Grand Resort,
Bentwood Tavern offers an upscale dining experience with a contemporary twist. This elegant restaurant features a sophisticated atmosphere, sleek furnishings, a cozy fireplace, and picturesque marina views. The menu at Bentwood Tavern showcases a diverse selection of dishes inspired by local ingredients and global flavors. Guests can indulge in seafood specialties, hand-cut steaks, and artisanal cocktails, all crafted with precision and care. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out with friends, Bentwood Tavern offers a culinary experience that is sure to impress.
4. Brewster's
11 W. Merchant St.
For those craving authentic Italian cuisine,
Brewster's is the place to be. This cozy eatery is known for its hearty pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and homemade desserts, all made from scratch using traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. Guests can dine in the charming dining room or enjoy al fresco dining on the outdoor patio, surrounded by lush greenery and twinkling lights. With its warm and welcoming ambiance and flavorful dishes, Brewster's Italian Cafe offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of New Buffalo.
5. Terrace Room
111 W. Water St.
The
Terrace Room at Harbor Grand is an elegant dining destination within the Harbor Grand Hotel. Situated just steps from the shores of Lake Michigan, this upscale restaurant offers stunning waterfront views and a refined atmosphere. The menu features a variety of seasonal dishes crafted with locally sourced ingredients and inspired by global flavors. From fresh seafood to tender steaks, each dish at the Terrace Room is expertly prepared and beautifully presented. Guests can also enjoy an extensive wine list curated to complement the flavors of each dish.
6. Oink's Dutch Treat
227 W. Buffalo St.
For a taste of nostalgia, look no further than
Oink's Dutch Treat, a beloved ice cream parlor in downtown New Buffalo. This family-owned shop has been serving sweet treats since 1974, delighting locals and visitors of all ages. Choose from hand-dipped ice cream flavors, including classic favorites like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, and unique creations like blue moon and butter pecan. Whether you're enjoying a cone on the go or treating yourself to a decadent sundae, Oink's Dutch Treat will satisfy your sweet cravings.
7. Casey's New Buffalo
136 N. Whittaker St.
Casey's New Buffalo is a popular sports bar and grill known for its casual atmosphere, friendly service, and mouthwatering pub fare. Located just steps from the beach, this laid-back eatery is a favorite among locals and tourists. Guests can enjoy a variety of classic comfort food dishes, including burgers, sandwiches, wings, and nachos, as well as a selection of craft beers and cocktails. With its spacious outdoor patio and multiple TVs airing the latest sports games, Casey's New Buffalo is the perfect spot to gather with friends and enjoy a relaxed dining experience.
8. Jackie's Cafe
801 W. Buffalo St.
Jackie's Cafe is a great find in downtown New Buffalo, offering a cozy atmosphere and delicious homemade dishes. This charming cafe specializes in breakfast and lunch favorites, including fluffy omelets, savory breakfast sandwiches, and hearty soups and salads. Guests can dine indoors or enjoy al fresco dining on the outdoor patio, surrounded by lush greenery and blooming flowers. With its friendly service and comforting cuisine, Jackie's Cafe provides a warm, welcoming dining experience that feels like home.
Want to explore New Buffalo as a local?
With its diverse culinary scene and vibrant atmosphere, New Buffalo offers many dining options to suit every taste and occasion. Whether you're in the mood for fresh seafood, gourmet burgers, or authentic Italian cuisine, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings in this charming lakeside town. From upscale eateries with waterfront views to cozy cafes serving homemade pastries, the best restaurants in New Buffalo provide a culinary experience that is sure to delight locals and visitors alike.
So, why wait? Explore the culinary delights of New Buffalo and indulge in a dining experience like no other.
Start your journey with Chad Gradowski
Ready to explore
homes for sale in New Buffalo? Contact
Chad Gradowski to begin your real estate journey. With his extensive local market knowledge and dedication to client satisfaction, Chad can help you find the perfect property to suit your lifestyle and budget.
*Header photo courtesy of The Harbor Grand Hotel
